WHY WE CARE


Plugged In exists to shine a light on the world of popular entertainment while giving you and your family the essential tools you need to understand, navigate and impact the culture in which we live. Through reviews, articles and discussions, we want to spark intellectual thought, spiritual growth and a desire to follow the command of Colossians 2:8: "See to it that no one takes you captive through hollow and deceptive philosophy, which depends on human tradition and the basic principles of this world rather than on Christ."

YOUR STORIES


Family uses Plugged In as a ‘significant compass’

"I am at a loss for words to adequately express how much it means to my husband and me to know that there is an organization like Focus that is rooting for us. Just today I was reading Psalm 37 and thinking about how your ministry provides ways to 'dwell in the land and enjoy safe pasture.' We have two teenagers and an 8-year-old in our household...Plugged In has become a significant compass for our family. All three of our kids are dedicated to their walk with Christ but they still encounter challenges. Thanks for all of your research and persistence in helping us navigate through stormy waters."

Plugged In helps college student stand-up for his belief

"Thanks for the great job you do in posting movie and television reviews online. I’m a college freshman and I recently had a confrontational disagreement with my English professor regarding an R-rated film. It is her favorite movie and she wanted to show it in class. I went to your Web site to research the film’s content. Although I had not seen the movie myself, I was able to make an educated argument against it based on the concerns you outlined. The prof said that she was impressed by my stand and decided to poll the whole class and give us a choice. We overwhelmingly voted to watch a G-rated movie instead! I’ve learned that I can trust your site and I will be using it a lot in the future.”

Plugged In brings ‘Sanity and Order’ to Non-believer

“Even though I don’t consider myself a Christian, I find your Plugged In Web site useful and thought-provoking. No one reviews movies like you do. Instead of being judgmental, you put entertainment ‘on trial.’ After presenting the evidence, you allow the jury of your readers to decide for themselves what they should do. In my opinion, you bring sanity and order to the wild world of modern day entertainment. Keep up the good work!”

Mom thinks Plugged In is the ‘BEST Christian media review site’

"Our family doesn't go to the movies until we go online and check out your assessment of a given film. I think this is the BEST Christian media review website that I've found, and I recommend it to my family and friends. Keep up the good work!"

SUPPORT THE WORK OF PLUGGED IN

Our hope is that whether you're a parent, youth leader or teen, the information and tools at Plugged In will help you and your family make appropriate media decisions. We are privileged to do the work we do, and are continually thankful for the generosity and support from you, our loyal readers, listeners and friends.

We hope this review was both interesting and useful. Please share it with family and friends who would benefit from it as well.

Book Review

Echo by Pam Muñoz Ryan has been reviewed by Focus on the Family’s marriage and parenting magazine.

Positive Elements

Spiritual Content

Sexual Content

Violent Content

Crude or Profane Language

Drug and Alcohol Content

Other Negative Elements

Conclusion

Pro-social Content

Objectionable Content

Summary Advisory

Plot Summary

During a game of hide-and-seek, Otto pauses to read a storybook about three lost princesses named Eins, Zwei and Drei, who are cast out by their father and raised by a witch in the forest. Otto gets lost in the woods. He trips and falls, knocking himself unconscious. When he wakes up, he finds himself with Eins, Zwei and Drei, who ask him to read them their own story.

In the story, the three sisters grow up doing household chores for the witch, who is indifferent to them. The sisters have magically beautiful voices, and they long to escape the witch’s cottage and have a happy family life. As the years pass, the old king dies, and the new king, the girls’ younger brother, learns of his three older sisters’ existence and invites them to his coronation.

The witch is angry that the sisters want to leave, so she curses them. They must remain in the forest unless two conditions are fulfilled. First, their spirits must enter a woodwind instrument to be carried away from the forest; second, they must save a soul about to die.

Otto stops reading the book because the pages end, and he tries to help the girls escape. He offers them his new harmonica. Each sister plays a short tune, which places her spirit inside the harmonica. The girls tell him that his fate will always tie him to the people who have played the harmonica before him and those who will play it afterward.

Otto wakes up the next morning, alone in the forest with no book. When he plays the harmonica, he feels his name being called and a path through the forest opening for him. The path leads him directly to a search party that is looking for him.

Although he tells his parents about the three sisters and the harmonica, they insist that the harmonica is not magical. As time goes by, Otto grows up and stops telling the story of the sisters, though he occasionally plays the harmonica when he feels afraid.

In 1933, in Trossingen, Germany, Friedrich Schmidt is a shy 12-year-old boy with a striking purple birthmark covering half his face. Adolf Hitler is the new chancellor of Germany, and Friedrich’s father despises Hitler’s increasingly narrow-minded laws and policies. Friedrich doesn’t attend school with other children. Instead, he works with his Uncle Gunter in a harmonica factory.

One day he hears a haunting melody coming from an abandoned warehouse next to the factory. In the warehouse, he discovers a harmonica that looks very old. He takes it home. As he plays it, he realizes that its music is more beautiful than any other harmonica he has played and that he feels braver. The harmonica is marked with a painted red letter “M,” distinguishing it from other harmonicas.

Friedrich is troubled when his older sister, Elisabeth, returns home from nursing school and reveals that she supports Hitler and his policies for creating a racially pure Germany. Elisabeth warns their father that because of Friedrich’s birthmark and his childhood bout of epilepsy, he will have to receive a sterilization surgery to ensure that he cannot pass on his genetic deformities to the next generation.

The situation in Trossingen worsens until Mr. Schmidt and Uncle Gunter realize they must leave Germany entirely. Before they can leave, Mr. Schmidt is taken into custody by the police and sent to a hard-labor camp in Dachau for being sympathetic to Jews and harboring anti-Nazi views. Friedrich prepares to travel to Dachau with a bribe so the camp will release his father, but he knows he must leave his beloved harmonica behind him or it will be confiscated when the guards search him.

In 1935 in Pennsylvania, 11-year-old piano prodigy Mike Flannery lives in the Bishop’s Home for Friendless and Destitute Children. His younger brother, Frankie, is only 7. Since their grandmother’s death, Mike is the only support system Frankie has.

A miracle seems to occur when a lawyer named Mr. Howard, representing the estate of a wealthy woman named Mrs. Sturbridge, says he needs to adopt a musically talented child on his client’s behalf, but is willing to take two. Mike and Frankie go to live at Mrs. Sturbridge’s mansion and are well-fed and well-treated by the staff, although they rarely see Mrs. Sturbridge herself.

Mike learns from Mr. Howard that Mrs. Sturbridge used to be a concert pianist, but she stopped playing after her only son’s death and her subsequent divorce from her husband. Mrs. Sturbridge’s late father wanted her to enjoy family life again, so he specified in his will that his daughter must adopt a child within one year of her father’s death or be left penniless.

Mike is devastated to know that Mrs. Sturbridge never wanted to adopt them in the first place and is actively looking for ways to legally reverse the adoption process. He begs Mrs. Sturbridge to at least care for Frankie, insisting that he can find his own way in the world. Mike intends to audition for Hoxie’s Harmonica Wizards, a traveling harmonica band of boys who are internationally famous. If he joins the group, he’ll have food and lodging until he’s old enough to find a permanent job.

Mrs. Sturbridge agrees to help Mike and gives him advice for polishing up his audition. Mr. Howard buys him a harmonica with a mysteriously musical quality, which has a red letter M painted on it. Mike makes it to the final auditions but decides to run away from home with Frankie when he learns that Mrs. Sturbridge has betrayed him by obtaining the paperwork to reverse Frankie’s adoption, as well as his own.

In 1942 in Southern California, Ivy Lopez’s parents are migrant farmers who wish she would think practically about her schoolwork, although her greatest love in life is music. Her older brother, Fernando, has joined the United States Army, and Ivy’s parents eagerly await letters from him. Ivy is crushed when a permanent farming position opens up, and she and her parents have to move to a new town immediately. Ivy takes her harmonica, a special one with the letter M painted on one corner, with her to her new city.

There are tensions in Ivy’s new town. The farm that Ivy lives on originally belonged to a Japanese family called the Yamamotos, who were removed from their home and confined in a camp by the U.S. government. When Ivy starts school, she’s surprised to learn that she’s not attending the Lincoln Main elementary school with her white friend, Susan, but Lincoln Annex, an Americanization school for children who are not considered citizens. The second school is inferior in every respect, and Ivy learns that her only opportunity to study at Lincoln Main will be after school hours, and only if she becomes a member of the elementary orchestra.

A neighbor, Mr. Ward, demands to search the extra buildings on the Yamamotos’ property because he believes they were spies. However, a thorough search only reveals a large collection of musical instruments belonging to Japanese friends of the Yamamotos who wanted to preserve their precious instruments before departing for internment camps. When Kenny Yamamoto, the grown son of the Yamamotos who is an interpreter with the Army, comes to visit the farm, Ivy feels compelled to give him her “M” harmonica.

In New York’s Carnegie Hall in 1951, Friedrich Schmidt is the conductor for the Empire Philharmonic Orchestra. He ushers his father and his Uncle Gunter to their seats before the performance. At the same venue, an adult Mike welcomes Frankie, Mrs. Sturbridge and Mr. Howard to watch him play the piano with the orchestra. Mike had been wrong about Mrs. Sturbridge not wanting to adopt him and Frankie. She married Mr. Howard, and the four of them became a happy family.

Ivy is also part of the concert as a flutist, distinguished by being the youngest member of the orchestra. Her old family friend Kenny Yamamoto is in the audience watching her. When she gave him the magic harmonica all those years ago, he returned to the action of World War II with the harmonica in his chest pocket. The harmonica stopped a bullet that would have killed him.

As he convalesced in the hospital, he saw a vision of three lost princesses tending to him because he was the soul on the brink of death that they were meant to save. Ivy plays beautifully in the concert, unaware of her connection to Friedrich and Mike, all of whom owned the same harmonica.

In a final chapter, the reader learns that the boy Otto grew up to become a famous harmonica maker and that he painted the red letter M on the magical harmonica and sent it out into the world, which allowed Friedrich, then Mike, then Ivy, then Kenny, to receive it.

Once the three princesses saved Kenny, the spell was broken, and they returned to their own timeline and lived happily ever after with their mother and brother in their castle.

Christian Beliefs

Various characters celebrate Christmas. Ivy’s family attends Catholic church.

Other Belief Systems

Friedrich’s father says that music is his religion. Hitler’s Nazi party is hostile toward Jewish people and toward the Star of David, the symbol of their faith.

An angry witch curses three princesses. They become spirits and live within a harmonica until they are able to save a soul about to die.

Authority Roles

Eins, Zwei and Drei’s father, the old king, is willing to let his female children die if it means that his kingdom will not be inherited by his younger brother. The witch who raises Eins, Zwei and Drei does not love them and only uses them for their labor.

Friedrich’s father, Mr. Schmidt, is a loving and supportive parental figure, encouraging his son’s independence. He finds an alternative life path for Friedrich as an apprentice at the harmonica factory when he can no longer attend traditional school. Friedrich’s Uncle Gunter is also a kind and warm parental figure to him.

Mike always cares for Frankie and looks after his well-being, as a parent would. Mr. Howard is kind to the boys and would adopt them if the law permitted. Mrs. Sturbridge is so wrapped up in her own grief over losing her son that she spends weeks blinded to the possibility that the children in her home might need love or attention.

Ivy’s parents are practical people who don’t have much patience for their young daughter’s imagination or her musical interests.

Profanity/Violence

Ivy sees the racially derogatory term Japs painted in graffiti on a door.

Kissing/Sex/Homosexuality

None

Discussion Topics

Get free discussion questions for this book and others, at FocusOnTheFamily.com/discuss-books.

Additional Comments/Notes

You can request a review of a title you can't find at reviewrequests@family.org.

Book reviews cover the content, themes and worldviews of fiction books, not their literary merit, and equip parents to decide whether a book is appropriate for their children. The inclusion of a book's review does not constitute an endorsement by Focus on the Family.

Episode Reviews

Credits

Rating

Readability Age Range

8 and up

Author

Pam Muñoz Ryan

Cast

Director

Distributor

Network

Performance

Record Label

Platform

Publisher

Scholastic Press, an imprint of Scholastic Inc

Released

On Video

Year Published

2015

Awards

Newberry Honor Book, 2016

Reviewer

We hope this review was both interesting and useful. Please share it with family and friends who would benefit from it as well.

Get weekly e-news, Culture Clips & more!